Skip to content
Discover expert reviews, top strategies, and the latest UK …

The Hidden Ecological Cost of Ultra-Processed Foods: Why the Industry Must Be Accountable

If you inspect a packet of M&M's, one of the best-selling sweets in the US, you'll see familiar ingredients like sugar, skimmed milk powder, and cocoa butter. However, many more items are unfamiliar: gum arabic, starch gum, carnauba wax, soy lecithin, and E100.

There are thirty-four ingredients in the candy, with no fewer than thirty countries involved in supplying them. Each has its own supply chain that transforms base substances into usable parts – beans into chocolate paste, plants into sweetener, petroleum into blue food dye.

These ingredients then journey across the world to a main manufacturing plant where they are mixed and converted into small multicolored chocolate gems.

It's becoming more widely recognized that food systems are a significant contributor of the climate crisis. Scientists can examine deforestation for agriculture or methane emissions from livestock. But the ecological footprint of ultra-processed foods – like M&Ms – is more ambiguous and is just beginning to come into focus. One reason they have been so difficult to assess is the inherent complexity of ultra-processed foods: these factory-produced items include a huge number of ingredients and processes to assemble them, making it extremely difficult to track.

But it doesn't mean it's unimportant. Since UPFs dominate American supermarkets and eating habits – they now account for seventy percent of food sold in grocery stores, and over 50% of calories consumed – experts say that understanding their ecological cost is critical to build a more climate-friendly agricultural system.

The Information We Know

While scientists are just beginning to examine the ecological effects of UPFs, what's already known about them is worrisome.

"The greater the processing products become, the more deleterious they are to human health and the planet," stated Anthony Fardet. The primary cause, he explains, is that the ingredients are so resource demanding. When combined, the toll balloons.

Consider the popular candy. The first step in creating the sweets is cultivating for cocoa, sugar, dairy and palm.

There is extensive evidence that farming for ingredients like cocoa drives ever increasing rates of forest clearance worldwide. Since 1850, agricultural expansion has driven almost 90% of global deforestation, which has been responsible for 30% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Large corporations have been called out in the past for agricultural methods in their supply chain, and have since developed environmental initiatives, but these do not resolve that large-scale agricultural practices are, fundamentally, unsustainable.

Additionally, sweetener, milk solids and palm fat – also significant greenhouse gas emitters.

On top of that are the factory-produced ingredients like artificial colors – possibly the hallmark of ultra-processing – which M&Ms contain 13 different types of. The blue candies are dyed with E132 and E133; these colorants are mostly made in food dye manufacturing hotspots Asia, through synthetic processes of aromatic hydrocarbons with chemical compounds, accelerated by the elements copper and chromium.

Producing soya lecithin, an ingredient made from soybean oil that's used to alter the texture of candy, requires procedures like oil refining in a heated vessel, extracting fat molecules, bleaching using chemical agents and drying under reduced air pressure. Similarly, a sweetener, begins as maize that gets soaked in chemicals before being milled, separated and dried. Afterward, it's broken down into smaller molecules using enzymes and acids, and then recrystallized.

While highly manufactured candies are some of the worst offenders, different types of ultra-processed foods are burdensome on the environment as well. Take for instance another popular snack, which has 39 components. Corn is the main ingredient, and for every hectare grown, one thousand kilograms of CO2 is emitted to the air. Similar to other corporations, producers have developed their own sustainability promises, but many of these promises are underpinned by practices that are considered greenwashing.

Consequently, some experts have begun estimating the ecological cost of UPFs.

One analysis calculated that popular candies generate at least thirteen point two kilograms of greenhouse gases per kilogram produced. With yearly output of more than six hundred million kilograms in the United States, this would mean that the products emit at least 3.8 million tons of carbon dioxide – accounting for 0.1% of yearly carbon output in the country. But, this is only an estimate based on accessible information; the actual impact is probably much higher, experts say.

There's a "black box" when it comes to carbon accounting in the processed food industry, says a professor who studies how corporations respond to the environmental challenge. "There exists so much ambiguity as supply chains get complex."

The Gaps We Have Yet to Discover

Calculating precisely of the ecological impact of ultra-processed foods is nearly impossible, since, by definition, UPFs consist of many ingredients and a significant number of non-transparent procedures. Components aren't just mixed together like one would do to make a home-cooked meal at home. Rather, these ingredients are altered synthetically, certain portions removed, and flavors, colors or textures incorporated – and it's unclear what the cost of these processes are because so many suppliers and parts are involved.

Another reason is that every ultra-processed food are the creations of food companies that have minimal motivation to reveal their ecological impact and might not comprehend it to start with.

For instance, large corporations don't farm primary components themselves, but instead depend on numerous growers that don't always have precise emissions tracking in place. This means that carbon output from large manufacturers may be underestimated. Analysts noted that corporations "lack actual data, so they use emissions factors, which are guesses."

Specialists say that corporations provide reports on straightforward aspects like shipping, which are easier to calculate, and often omit or convolute the farming-related carbon of their items. Ultimately, reporting high emissions goes against the objectives of major manufacturers, so the complex calculations needed to establish the environmental impact of industrial farming and multi-step industrial chemical processes used to make processed food components remain un-researched.

"The main point of manufactured products is profit," stated the researcher, pointing out that they're designed to be appealing, convenient and pleasurable to eat.

"Most of the people in the manufacturing sector's production network don't care about climate change from an ethical perspective, but they are interested in profit," explained another expert. He explains that to change these motivations, the value of foods and ingredients would need to include their effect on our global environment. But that would require official policies and financial penalties based on the true environmental cost of ultra-processed foods.

Why It Is Important

For less than two dollars, the cost of M&Ms at the supermarket barely represents their real impact on the planet. But to tackle these issues with manufactured products, more than just a few tweaks to the component selection are needed.

"Lowering the sodium, or sweetener of just one product is just superficial eco-marketing," stated Fardet. "It is necessary to transform the whole picture." To do that, he suggested consuming more regionally produced, unprocessed items, which frequently take far fewer resources and transit to produce, and therefore have a much smaller carbon footprint.

Unique products that can't be sourced locally, like cocoa items, should {make up|constitute

Written by

Christina Patrick

A seasoned UK gaming journalist with over a decade of experience in online slots analysis and casino industry insights.

Slots Brit 360

Type to search articles.